Negative data refers to research findings that do not support a hypothesis, do not reach statistical significance, or indicate the absence of an expected effect or event. Both positive and negative findings contribute to scientific progress by providing a more complete and balanced understanding of research outcomes, helping to avoid unnecessary duplication of studies and informing future investigations.
However, published literature remains heavily weighted towards positive findings. In biology alone, an estimated 85–90% of published papers report positive results. This imbalance creates a distorted representation of the evidence base, limits the visibility of negative findings and contributes to duplicated research efforts and wasted resources.
In this, two-part conversation session we'll hear the shift in this narrative via the experience of an academic and a data manager:
Talk 1: Prof Devang Mehta will share his experience of publishing work on a genome editing technique for a recurring plant disease, which produced what is widely seen as 'negative' data.
Talk 2: Dr Naeem Muhammad will share how good research data management preserves the intrinsic value of negative findings by making outputs FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable), well-documented, and publishable as dedicated data articles.
About the speakers:
Prof Devang Mehta is a tenure-track Special Research Fund Professor in the Faculty of Bioscience Engineering at KU Leuven, Belgium, where his lab uses circadian biology to engineer climate-resilient plant traits, including latitudinal adaptation. He received the Carl Douglas Award from the Canadian Society of Plant Biologists in recognition of his significant contributions to plant proteomics.
Dr Naeem Muhammad is the Founder of DataAI.be, a Belgium-based consultancy specialising in Open Science, Research Data Management (RDM), FAIR data and AI-enabled research support. With nearly two decades of experience, he advises government bodies, universities, research organisations and international projects across Europe and Latin America.
If you have any questions regarding any of these sessions, please get in touch at rdm@sheffield.ac.uk
The University of Sheffield Library runs the ‘How to Share…’ seminar series that contains short, bitesize seminars that look at how best to share different research data types to help you make your research outputs more FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable and Reusable) and open. Recordings from past sessions are available here.